lkml.org 
[lkml]   [2020]   [Nov]   [2]   [last100]   RSS Feed
Views: [wrap][no wrap]   [headers]  [forward] 
 
Messages in this thread
/
From
Date
SubjectRe: [PATCH v1] sched/fair: update_pick_idlest() Select group with lowest group_util when idle_cpus are equal
On Mon, 2 Nov 2020 at 11:50, Mel Gorman <mgorman@techsingularity.net> wrote:
>
> On Tue, Jul 14, 2020 at 08:59:41AM -0400, peter.puhov@linaro.org wrote:
> > From: Peter Puhov <peter.puhov@linaro.org>
> >
> > v0: https://lkml.org/lkml/2020/6/16/1286
> >
> > Changes in v1:
> > - Test results formatted in a table form as suggested by Valentin Schneider
> > - Added explanation by Vincent Guittot why nr_running may not be sufficient
> >
> > In slow path, when selecting idlest group, if both groups have type
> > group_has_spare, only idle_cpus count gets compared.
> > As a result, if multiple tasks are created in a tight loop,
> > and go back to sleep immediately
> > (while waiting for all tasks to be created),
> > they may be scheduled on the same core, because CPU is back to idle
> > when the new fork happen.
> >
>
> Intuitively, this made some sense but it's a regression magnet. For those
> that don't know, I run a grid that among other things, operates similar to
> the Intel 0-day bot but runs much long-lived tests on a less frequent basis
> -- can be a few weeks, sometimes longer depending on the grid activity.
> Where it finds regressions, it bisects them and generates a report.
>
> While all tests have not completed, I currently have 14 separate
> regressions across 4 separate tests on 6 machines which are Broadwell,
> Haswell and EPYC 2 machines (all x86_64 of course but different generations
> and vendors). The workload configurations in mmtests are
>
> pagealloc-performance-aim9
> workload-shellscripts
> workload-kerndevel
> scheduler-unbound-hackbench
>
> When reading the reports, the first and second columns are what it was
> bisecting against. The second 3rd last commit is the "last good commit"
> and the last column is "first bad commit". The first bad commit is always
> this patch
>
> The main concern is that all of these workloads have very short-lived tasks
> which is exactly what this patch is meant to address so either sysbench
> and futex behave very differently on the machine that was tested or their
> microbenchmark nature found one good corner case but missed bad ones.
>
> I have not investigated why because I do not have the bandwidth
> to do a detailed study (I was off for a few days and my backlog is
> severe). However, I recommend in before v5.10 this be reverted and retried.
> If I'm cc'd on v2, I'll run the same tests through the grid and see what
> falls out.

I'm going to have a look at the regressions and see if patches that
have been queued for v5.10 or even more recent patch can help or if
the patch should be adjusted

>
> I'll show one example of each workload from one machine.
>
> pagealloc-performance-aim9
> --------------------------
>
> While multiple tests are shown, the exec_test and fork_test are
> regressing and these are very short lived. 67% regression for exec_test
> and 32% regression for fork_test
>
> initial initial last penup last penup first
> good-v5.8 bad-v5.9 bad-58934356 bad-e0078e2e good-46132e3a good-aa93cd53 bad-3edecfef
> Min page_test 522580.00 ( 0.00%) 537880.00 ( 2.93%) 536842.11 ( 2.73%) 542300.00 ( 3.77%) 537993.33 ( 2.95%) 526660.00 ( 0.78%) 532553.33 ( 1.91%)
> Min brk_test 1987866.67 ( 0.00%) 2028666.67 ( 2.05%) 2016200.00 ( 1.43%) 2014856.76 ( 1.36%) 2004663.56 ( 0.84%) 1984466.67 ( -0.17%) 2025266.67 ( 1.88%)
> Min exec_test 877.75 ( 0.00%) 284.33 ( -67.61%) 285.14 ( -67.51%) 285.14 ( -67.51%) 852.10 ( -2.92%) 932.05 ( 6.19%) 285.62 ( -67.46%)
> Min fork_test 3213.33 ( 0.00%) 2154.26 ( -32.96%) 2180.85 ( -32.13%) 2214.10 ( -31.10%) 3257.83 ( 1.38%) 4154.46 ( 29.29%) 2194.15 ( -31.72%)
> Hmean page_test 544508.39 ( 0.00%) 545446.23 ( 0.17%) 542617.62 ( -0.35%) 546829.87 ( 0.43%) 546439.04 ( 0.35%) 541806.49 ( -0.50%) 546895.25 ( 0.44%)
> Hmean brk_test 2054683.48 ( 0.00%) 2061982.39 ( 0.36%) 2029765.65 * -1.21%* 2031996.84 * -1.10%* 2040844.18 ( -0.67%) 2009345.37 * -2.21%* 2063861.59 ( 0.45%)
> Hmean exec_test 896.88 ( 0.00%) 284.71 * -68.26%* 285.65 * -68.15%* 285.45 * -68.17%* 902.85 ( 0.67%) 943.16 * 5.16%* 286.26 * -68.08%*
> Hmean fork_test 3394.50 ( 0.00%) 2200.37 * -35.18%* 2243.49 * -33.91%* 2244.58 * -33.88%* 3757.31 * 10.69%* 4228.87 * 24.58%* 2237.46 * -34.09%*
> Stddev page_test 7358.98 ( 0.00%) 3713.10 ( 49.54%) 3177.20 ( 56.83%) 1988.97 ( 72.97%) 5174.09 ( 29.69%) 5755.98 ( 21.78%) 6270.80 ( 14.79%)
> Stddev brk_test 21505.08 ( 0.00%) 20373.25 ( 5.26%) 9123.25 ( 57.58%) 8935.31 ( 58.45%) 26933.95 ( -25.24%) 11606.00 ( 46.03%) 20779.25 ( 3.38%)
> Stddev exec_test 13.64 ( 0.00%) 0.36 ( 97.37%) 0.34 ( 97.49%) 0.22 ( 98.38%) 30.95 (-126.92%) 8.43 ( 38.22%) 0.48 ( 96.52%)
> Stddev fork_test 115.45 ( 0.00%) 37.57 ( 67.46%) 37.22 ( 67.76%) 22.53 ( 80.49%) 274.45 (-137.72%) 32.78 ( 71.61%) 24.24 ( 79.01%)
> CoeffVar page_test 1.35 ( 0.00%) 0.68 ( 49.62%) 0.59 ( 56.67%) 0.36 ( 73.08%) 0.95 ( 29.93%) 1.06 ( 21.39%) 1.15 ( 15.15%)
> CoeffVar brk_test 1.05 ( 0.00%) 0.99 ( 5.60%) 0.45 ( 57.05%) 0.44 ( 57.98%) 1.32 ( -26.09%) 0.58 ( 44.81%) 1.01 ( 3.80%)
> CoeffVar exec_test 1.52 ( 0.00%) 0.13 ( 91.71%) 0.12 ( 92.11%) 0.08 ( 94.92%) 3.42 (-125.23%) 0.89 ( 41.24%) 0.17 ( 89.08%)
> CoeffVar fork_test 3.40 ( 0.00%) 1.71 ( 49.76%) 1.66 ( 51.19%) 1.00 ( 70.46%) 7.27 (-113.89%) 0.78 ( 77.19%) 1.08 ( 68.12%)
> Max page_test 553633.33 ( 0.00%) 548986.67 ( -0.84%) 546355.76 ( -1.31%) 549666.67 ( -0.72%) 553746.67 ( 0.02%) 547286.67 ( -1.15%) 558620.00 ( 0.90%)
> Max brk_test 2068087.94 ( 0.00%) 2081933.33 ( 0.67%) 2044533.33 ( -1.14%) 2045436.38 ( -1.10%) 2074000.00 ( 0.29%) 2027315.12 ( -1.97%) 2081933.33 ( 0.67%)
> Max exec_test 927.33 ( 0.00%) 285.14 ( -69.25%) 286.28 ( -69.13%) 285.81 ( -69.18%) 951.00 ( 2.55%) 959.33 ( 3.45%) 287.14 ( -69.04%)
> Max fork_test 3597.60 ( 0.00%) 2267.29 ( -36.98%) 2296.94 ( -36.15%) 2282.10 ( -36.57%) 4054.59 ( 12.70%) 4297.14 ( 19.44%) 2290.28 ( -36.34%)
> BHmean-50 page_test 547854.63 ( 0.00%) 547923.82 ( 0.01%) 545184.27 ( -0.49%) 548296.84 ( 0.08%) 550707.83 ( 0.52%) 545502.70 ( -0.43%) 550981.79 ( 0.57%)
> BHmean-50 brk_test 2063783.93 ( 0.00%) 2077311.93 ( 0.66%) 2036886.71 ( -1.30%) 2038740.90 ( -1.21%) 2066350.82 ( 0.12%) 2017773.76 ( -2.23%) 2078929.15 ( 0.73%)
> BHmean-50 exec_test 906.22 ( 0.00%) 285.04 ( -68.55%) 285.94 ( -68.45%) 285.63 ( -68.48%) 928.41 ( 2.45%) 949.48 ( 4.77%) 286.65 ( -68.37%)
> BHmean-50 fork_test 3485.94 ( 0.00%) 2230.56 ( -36.01%) 2273.16 ( -34.79%) 2263.22 ( -35.08%) 3973.97 ( 14.00%) 4249.44 ( 21.90%) 2254.13 ( -35.34%)
> BHmean-95 page_test 546593.48 ( 0.00%) 546144.64 ( -0.08%) 543148.84 ( -0.63%) 547245.43 ( 0.12%) 547220.00 ( 0.11%) 543226.76 ( -0.62%) 548237.46 ( 0.30%)
> BHmean-95 brk_test 2060981.15 ( 0.00%) 2065065.44 ( 0.20%) 2031007.95 ( -1.45%) 2033569.50 ( -1.33%) 2044198.19 ( -0.81%) 2011638.04 ( -2.39%) 2067443.29 ( 0.31%)
> BHmean-95 exec_test 898.66 ( 0.00%) 284.74 ( -68.31%) 285.70 ( -68.21%) 285.48 ( -68.23%) 907.76 ( 1.01%) 944.19 ( 5.07%) 286.32 ( -68.14%)
> BHmean-95 fork_test 3411.98 ( 0.00%) 2204.66 ( -35.38%) 2249.37 ( -34.07%) 2247.40 ( -34.13%) 3810.42 ( 11.68%) 4235.77 ( 24.14%) 2241.48 ( -34.31%)
> BHmean-99 page_test 546593.48 ( 0.00%) 546144.64 ( -0.08%) 543148.84 ( -0.63%) 547245.43 ( 0.12%) 547220.00 ( 0.11%) 543226.76 ( -0.62%) 548237.46 ( 0.30%)
> BHmean-99 brk_test 2060981.15 ( 0.00%) 2065065.44 ( 0.20%) 2031007.95 ( -1.45%) 2033569.50 ( -1.33%) 2044198.19 ( -0.81%) 2011638.04 ( -2.39%) 2067443.29 ( 0.31%)
> BHmean-99 exec_test 898.66 ( 0.00%) 284.74 ( -68.31%) 285.70 ( -68.21%) 285.48 ( -68.23%) 907.76 ( 1.01%) 944.19 ( 5.07%) 286.32 ( -68.14%)
> BHmean-99 fork_test 3411.98 ( 0.00%) 2204.66 ( -35.38%) 2249.37 ( -34.07%) 2247.40 ( -34.13%) 3810.42 ( 11.68%) 4235.77 ( 24.14%) 2241.48 ( -34.31%)
>
> workload-shellscripts
> ---------------------
>
> This is the git test suite. It's mostly sequential that executes lots of
> small short-lived tasks
>
> Comparison
> ==========
> initial initial last penup last penup first
> good-v5.8 bad-v5.9 bad-58934356 bad-e0078e2e good-46132e3a good-aa93cd53 bad-3edecfef
> Min User 798.92 ( 0.00%) 897.51 ( -12.34%) 894.39 ( -11.95%) 896.18 ( -12.17%) 799.34 ( -0.05%) 796.94 ( 0.25%) 894.75 ( -11.99%)
> Min System 479.24 ( 0.00%) 603.24 ( -25.87%) 596.36 ( -24.44%) 597.34 ( -24.64%) 484.00 ( -0.99%) 482.64 ( -0.71%) 599.17 ( -25.03%)
> Min Elapsed 1225.72 ( 0.00%) 1443.47 ( -17.77%) 1434.25 ( -17.01%) 1434.08 ( -17.00%) 1230.97 ( -0.43%) 1226.47 ( -0.06%) 1436.45 ( -17.19%)
> Min CPU 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%)
> Amean User 799.84 ( 0.00%) 899.00 * -12.40%* 896.15 * -12.04%* 897.33 * -12.19%* 800.47 ( -0.08%) 797.96 * 0.23%* 896.35 * -12.07%*
> Amean System 480.68 ( 0.00%) 605.14 * -25.89%* 598.59 * -24.53%* 599.63 * -24.75%* 485.92 * -1.09%* 483.51 * -0.59%* 600.67 * -24.96%*
> Amean Elapsed 1226.35 ( 0.00%) 1444.06 * -17.75%* 1434.57 * -16.98%* 1436.62 * -17.15%* 1231.60 * -0.43%* 1228.06 ( -0.14%) 1436.65 * -17.15%*
> Amean CPU 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%)
> Stddev User 0.79 ( 0.00%) 1.20 ( -51.32%) 1.32 ( -65.89%) 1.07 ( -35.47%) 1.12 ( -40.77%) 1.08 ( -36.32%) 1.38 ( -73.53%)
> Stddev System 0.90 ( 0.00%) 1.26 ( -40.06%) 1.73 ( -91.63%) 1.50 ( -66.48%) 1.08 ( -20.06%) 0.74 ( 17.38%) 1.04 ( -15.98%)
> Stddev Elapsed 0.44 ( 0.00%) 0.53 ( -18.89%) 0.28 ( 36.46%) 1.77 (-298.99%) 0.53 ( -19.49%) 2.02 (-356.27%) 0.24 ( 46.45%)
> Stddev CPU 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%)
> CoeffVar User 0.10 ( 0.00%) 0.13 ( -34.63%) 0.15 ( -48.07%) 0.12 ( -20.75%) 0.14 ( -40.66%) 0.14 ( -36.64%) 0.15 ( -54.85%)
> CoeffVar System 0.19 ( 0.00%) 0.21 ( -11.26%) 0.29 ( -53.88%) 0.25 ( -33.45%) 0.22 ( -18.76%) 0.15 ( 17.86%) 0.17 ( 7.19%)
> CoeffVar Elapsed 0.04 ( 0.00%) 0.04 ( -0.96%) 0.02 ( 45.68%) 0.12 (-240.59%) 0.04 ( -18.98%) 0.16 (-355.64%) 0.02 ( 54.29%)
> CoeffVar CPU 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%) 0.00 ( 0.00%)
> Max User 801.05 ( 0.00%) 900.27 ( -12.39%) 897.95 ( -12.10%) 899.06 ( -12.24%) 802.29 ( -0.15%) 799.47 ( 0.20%) 898.39 ( -12.15%)
> Max System 481.60 ( 0.00%) 606.40 ( -25.91%) 600.94 ( -24.78%) 601.51 ( -24.90%) 486.59 ( -1.04%) 484.23 ( -0.55%) 602.04 ( -25.01%)
> Max Elapsed 1226.94 ( 0.00%) 1444.85 ( -17.76%) 1434.89 ( -16.95%) 1438.52 ( -17.24%) 1232.42 ( -0.45%) 1231.52 ( -0.37%) 1437.04 ( -17.12%)
> Max CPU 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%)
> BAmean-50 User 799.16 ( 0.00%) 897.73 ( -12.33%) 895.06 ( -12.00%) 896.51 ( -12.18%) 799.68 ( -0.07%) 797.09 ( 0.26%) 895.20 ( -12.02%)
> BAmean-50 System 479.89 ( 0.00%) 603.93 ( -25.85%) 597.00 ( -24.40%) 598.39 ( -24.69%) 485.10 ( -1.09%) 482.75 ( -0.60%) 599.83 ( -24.99%)
> BAmean-50 Elapsed 1225.99 ( 0.00%) 1443.59 ( -17.75%) 1434.34 ( -16.99%) 1434.97 ( -17.05%) 1231.20 ( -0.42%) 1226.66 ( -0.05%) 1436.47 ( -17.17%)
> BAmean-50 CPU 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%)
> BAmean-95 User 799.53 ( 0.00%) 898.68 ( -12.40%) 895.69 ( -12.03%) 896.90 ( -12.18%) 800.01 ( -0.06%) 797.58 ( 0.24%) 895.85 ( -12.05%)
> BAmean-95 System 480.45 ( 0.00%) 604.82 ( -25.89%) 598.01 ( -24.47%) 599.16 ( -24.71%) 485.75 ( -1.10%) 483.33 ( -0.60%) 600.33 ( -24.95%)
> BAmean-95 Elapsed 1226.21 ( 0.00%) 1443.86 ( -17.75%) 1434.49 ( -16.99%) 1436.15 ( -17.12%) 1231.40 ( -0.42%) 1227.20 ( -0.08%) 1436.55 ( -17.15%)
> BAmean-95 CPU 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%)
> BAmean-99 User 799.53 ( 0.00%) 898.68 ( -12.40%) 895.69 ( -12.03%) 896.90 ( -12.18%) 800.01 ( -0.06%) 797.58 ( 0.24%) 895.85 ( -12.05%)
> BAmean-99 System 480.45 ( 0.00%) 604.82 ( -25.89%) 598.01 ( -24.47%) 599.16 ( -24.71%) 485.75 ( -1.10%) 483.33 ( -0.60%) 600.33 ( -24.95%)
> BAmean-99 Elapsed 1226.21 ( 0.00%) 1443.86 ( -17.75%) 1434.49 ( -16.99%) 1436.15 ( -17.12%) 1231.40 ( -0.42%) 1227.20 ( -0.08%) 1436.55 ( -17.15%)
> BAmean-99 CPU 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%) 104.00 ( 0.00%)
>
> This is showing a 17% regression in the time to complete the test
>
> workload-kerndevel
> ------------------
>
> This is a kernel building benchmark varying the number of subjobs with
> -J
>
> initial initial last penup last penup first
> good-v5.8 bad-v5.9 bad-58934356 bad-e0078e2e good-46132e3a good-aa93cd53 bad-3edecfef
> Amean syst-2 138.51 ( 0.00%) 169.35 * -22.26%* 170.13 * -22.83%* 169.12 * -22.09%* 136.47 * 1.47%* 137.73 ( 0.57%) 169.24 * -22.18%*
> Amean elsp-2 489.41 ( 0.00%) 542.92 * -10.93%* 548.96 * -12.17%* 544.82 * -11.32%* 485.33 * 0.83%* 487.26 ( 0.44%) 542.35 * -10.82%*
> Amean syst-4 148.11 ( 0.00%) 171.27 * -15.63%* 171.14 * -15.55%* 170.82 * -15.33%* 146.13 * 1.34%* 146.38 * 1.17%* 170.52 * -15.13%*
> Amean elsp-4 266.90 ( 0.00%) 285.40 * -6.93%* 286.50 * -7.34%* 285.14 * -6.83%* 263.71 * 1.20%* 264.76 * 0.80%* 285.88 * -7.11%*
> Amean syst-8 158.64 ( 0.00%) 167.19 * -5.39%* 166.95 * -5.24%* 165.54 * -4.35%* 157.12 * 0.96%* 157.69 * 0.60%* 166.78 * -5.13%*
> Amean elsp-8 148.42 ( 0.00%) 151.32 * -1.95%* 154.00 * -3.76%* 151.64 * -2.17%* 147.79 ( 0.42%) 148.90 ( -0.32%) 152.56 * -2.79%*
> Amean syst-16 165.21 ( 0.00%) 166.41 * -0.73%* 166.96 * -1.06%* 166.17 ( -0.58%) 164.32 * 0.54%* 164.05 * 0.70%* 165.80 ( -0.36%)
> Amean elsp-16 83.17 ( 0.00%) 83.23 ( -0.07%) 83.75 ( -0.69%) 83.48 ( -0.37%) 83.08 ( 0.12%) 83.07 ( 0.12%) 83.27 ( -0.12%)
> Amean syst-32 164.42 ( 0.00%) 164.43 ( -0.00%) 164.43 ( -0.00%) 163.40 * 0.62%* 163.38 * 0.63%* 163.18 * 0.76%* 163.70 * 0.44%*
> Amean elsp-32 47.81 ( 0.00%) 48.83 * -2.14%* 48.64 * -1.73%* 48.46 ( -1.36%) 48.28 ( -0.97%) 48.16 ( -0.74%) 48.15 ( -0.71%)
> Amean syst-64 189.79 ( 0.00%) 192.63 * -1.50%* 191.19 * -0.74%* 190.86 * -0.56%* 189.08 ( 0.38%) 188.52 * 0.67%* 190.52 ( -0.39%)
> Amean elsp-64 35.49 ( 0.00%) 35.89 ( -1.13%) 36.39 * -2.51%* 35.93 ( -1.23%) 34.69 * 2.28%* 35.52 ( -0.06%) 35.60 ( -0.30%)
> Amean syst-128 200.15 ( 0.00%) 202.72 * -1.28%* 202.34 * -1.09%* 200.98 * -0.41%* 200.56 ( -0.20%) 198.12 * 1.02%* 201.01 * -0.43%*
> Amean elsp-128 34.34 ( 0.00%) 34.99 * -1.89%* 34.92 * -1.68%* 34.90 * -1.61%* 34.51 * -0.50%* 34.37 ( -0.08%) 35.02 * -1.98%*
> Amean syst-160 197.14 ( 0.00%) 199.39 * -1.14%* 198.76 * -0.82%* 197.71 ( -0.29%) 196.62 ( 0.26%) 195.55 * 0.81%* 197.06 ( 0.04%)
> Amean elsp-160 34.51 ( 0.00%) 35.15 * -1.87%* 35.14 * -1.83%* 35.06 * -1.61%* 34.29 * 0.63%* 34.43 ( 0.23%) 35.10 * -1.73%*
>
> This is showing a 10.93% regression in elapsed time with just two jobs
> (elsp-2). The regression goes away when there are a number of jobs so
> it's short-lived tasks on a mostly idle machine that is a problem
> Interestingly, it shows a lot of additional system CPU usage time
> (syst-2) so it's probable that the issue can be inferred from perf with
> a perf diff to show where all the extra time is being lost.
>
> While I say workload-kerndevel, I actually was using a modified version of
> the configuration that tested ext4 and xfs on test partitions. Both show
> regressions so this is not filesystem-specific (without the modification,
> the base filesystem would be btrfs on my test grid which some would find
> less interesting)
>
> scheduler-unbound-hackbench
> ---------------------------
>
> I don't think hackbench needs an introduction. It's varying the number
> of groups but as each group has lots of tasks, the machine is heavily
> loaded.
>
> initial initial last penup last penup first
> good-v5.8 bad-22fbc037cd32 bad-58934356 bad-e0078e2e good-46132e3a good-aa93cd53 bad-3edecfef
> Min 1 0.6470 ( 0.00%) 0.5200 ( 19.63%) 0.6730 ( -4.02%) 0.5230 ( 19.17%) 0.6620 ( -2.32%) 0.6740 ( -4.17%) 0.6170 ( 4.64%)
> Min 4 0.7510 ( 0.00%) 0.7460 ( 0.67%) 0.7230 ( 3.73%) 0.7450 ( 0.80%) 0.7540 ( -0.40%) 0.7490 ( 0.27%) 0.7520 ( -0.13%)
> Min 7 0.8140 ( 0.00%) 0.8300 ( -1.97%) 0.7880 ( 3.19%) 0.7880 ( 3.19%) 0.7870 ( 3.32%) 0.8170 ( -0.37%) 0.7990 ( 1.84%)
> Min 12 0.9500 ( 0.00%) 0.9140 ( 3.79%) 0.9070 ( 4.53%) 0.9200 ( 3.16%) 0.9290 ( 2.21%) 0.9180 ( 3.37%) 0.9070 ( 4.53%)
> Min 21 1.2210 ( 0.00%) 1.1560 ( 5.32%) 1.1230 ( 8.03%) 1.1480 ( 5.98%) 1.2730 ( -4.26%) 1.2010 ( 1.64%) 1.1610 ( 4.91%)
> Min 30 1.6500 ( 0.00%) 1.5960 ( 3.27%) 1.5010 ( 9.03%) 1.5620 ( 5.33%) 1.6130 ( 2.24%) 1.5920 ( 3.52%) 1.5540 ( 5.82%)
> Min 48 2.2550 ( 0.00%) 2.2610 ( -0.27%) 2.2040 ( 2.26%) 2.1940 ( 2.71%) 2.1090 ( 6.47%) 2.0910 ( 7.27%) 2.1300 ( 5.54%)
> Min 79 2.9090 ( 0.00%) 3.3210 ( -14.16%) 3.2140 ( -10.48%) 3.1310 ( -7.63%) 2.8970 ( 0.41%) 3.0400 ( -4.50%) 3.2590 ( -12.03%)
> Min 110 3.5080 ( 0.00%) 4.2600 ( -21.44%) 4.0060 ( -14.20%) 4.1110 ( -17.19%) 3.6680 ( -4.56%) 3.5370 ( -0.83%) 4.0550 ( -15.59%)
> Min 141 4.1840 ( 0.00%) 4.8090 ( -14.94%) 4.9600 ( -18.55%) 4.7310 ( -13.07%) 4.3650 ( -4.33%) 4.2590 ( -1.79%) 4.8320 ( -15.49%)
> Min 172 5.2690 ( 0.00%) 5.6350 ( -6.95%) 5.6140 ( -6.55%) 5.5550 ( -5.43%) 5.0390 ( 4.37%) 5.0940 ( 3.32%) 5.8190 ( -10.44%)
> Amean 1 0.6867 ( 0.00%) 0.6470 ( 5.78%) 0.6830 ( 0.53%) 0.5993 ( 12.72%) 0.6857 ( 0.15%) 0.6897 ( -0.44%) 0.6600 ( 3.88%)
> Amean 4 0.7603 ( 0.00%) 0.7477 ( 1.67%) 0.7413 ( 2.50%) 0.7517 ( 1.14%) 0.7667 ( -0.83%) 0.7557 ( 0.61%) 0.7583 ( 0.26%)
> Amean 7 0.8377 ( 0.00%) 0.8347 ( 0.36%) 0.8333 ( 0.52%) 0.7997 * 4.54%* 0.8160 ( 2.59%) 0.8323 ( 0.64%) 0.8183 ( 2.31%)
> Amean 12 0.9653 ( 0.00%) 0.9390 ( 2.73%) 0.9173 * 4.97%* 0.9357 ( 3.07%) 0.9460 ( 2.00%) 0.9383 ( 2.80%) 0.9230 * 4.39%*
> Amean 21 1.2400 ( 0.00%) 1.2260 ( 1.13%) 1.1733 ( 5.38%) 1.1833 * 4.57%* 1.2893 * -3.98%* 1.2620 ( -1.77%) 1.2043 ( 2.88%)
> Amean 30 1.6743 ( 0.00%) 1.6393 ( 2.09%) 1.5530 * 7.25%* 1.6070 ( 4.02%) 1.6293 ( 2.69%) 1.6167 * 3.44%* 1.6280 ( 2.77%)
> Amean 48 2.2760 ( 0.00%) 2.2987 ( -1.00%) 2.2257 * 2.21%* 2.2423 ( 1.48%) 2.1843 * 4.03%* 2.1687 * 4.72%* 2.1890 * 3.82%*
> Amean 79 3.0977 ( 0.00%) 3.3847 * -9.27%* 3.2540 ( -5.05%) 3.2367 ( -4.49%) 3.0067 ( 2.94%) 3.1263 ( -0.93%) 3.2983 ( -6.48%)
> Amean 110 3.6460 ( 0.00%) 4.3140 * -18.32%* 4.1720 * -14.43%* 4.1980 * -15.14%* 3.7230 ( -2.11%) 3.6990 ( -1.45%) 4.1790 * -14.62%*
> Amean 141 4.2420 ( 0.00%) 4.9697 * -17.15%* 4.9973 * -17.81%* 4.8940 * -15.37%* 4.4057 * -3.86%* 4.3493 ( -2.53%) 4.9610 * -16.95%*
> Amean 172 5.2830 ( 0.00%) 5.8717 * -11.14%* 5.7370 * -8.59%* 5.8280 * -10.32%* 5.0943 * 3.57%* 5.1083 * 3.31%* 5.9720 * -13.04%*
>
> This is showing 12% regression for 79 groups. This one is interesting
> because EPYC2 seems to be the one that is most affected by this. EPYC2
> has a different topology that a similar X86 machine in that it has
> multiple last-level caches so the sched domain groups it looks at are
> smaller than happens on other machines.
>
> Given the number of machines and workloads affected, can we revert and
> retry? I have not tested against current mainline as scheduler details
> have changed again but I can do so if desired.
>
> --
> Mel Gorman
> SUSE Labs

\
 
 \ /
  Last update: 2020-11-02 12:06    [W:0.094 / U:24.804 seconds]
©2003-2020 Jasper Spaans|hosted at Digital Ocean and TransIP|Read the blog|Advertise on this site